Drop The Mix: Pancakes From Scratch Are Surprisingly Easy

by Trish
Pancakes can be polarizing things. Some like them thin and crispy. Others, including myself, opt to put the emphasis on ‘cake’ and prefer them light and fluffy. Fluffy pancakes mean better absorption of maple syrup, and really isn’t a pancake just a big syrup sponge anyways?
While there are lots of great variations for pancakes (buttermilk, banana, blueberry, recipes for which will be coming in the near future) let’s nail down the perfect purist pancake before dabbling with other departures. So if the perfect pancake is fluffy, how do we achieve the fluff?
Some recipes will get fancy and have you separate eggs, beating whites, folding to combine etc. This does produce fluffy pancakes, but let’s not forget that this is breakfast. It’s Saturday morning and I’m in my jammies - there will be no whisking of egg whites. Thankfully it’s an unnecessary step and we’ll instead turn to our good friend baking powder for the leavening magic.
But baking powder isn’t exactly the same as the rest of your dry pantry items, and it will lose its oomph over time. So if you want your pancakes to puff up a mile high, you’ll need baking powder that you bought within the last three months or so. (It will often have an expiry date stamped on the bottom.) If you don’t bake often, do yourself a favor and toss the old stuff in the garbage and buy a new container. And you can test to see if your baking powder is still good by dumping a teaspoon or two in boiling water. If it fizzes up, you’re in business. If it’s flat, then that’s exactly what your pancakes will be.
Now that you know your baking powder works, let’s talk about how. Baking powder reacts in two different scenarios: once when it comes in contact with water and liquids and again when it’s heated. In order to capitalize on the chemical reaction, we’re going to want to minimize the time from when the powder hits the liquid to when it ends up in the hot pan. Preheat the pan while you prepare the recipe so your batter will be able to go directly into the hot pan with no delay.
Enough with the chemistry, then. My last word of advice is to add a little less milk than called for so the batter is only a bit thinner than muffin batter. This way it won’t spread out in the pan and be… wait for it, fluffier!

Pancakes
Time: 5 minutes to make, 15 minutes or so to cook
Yields 6 pancakes, perfect for 2 people.
- 1 egg
- 1 cup flour
- scant 3/4 cup milk
- 1 tablespoon sugar
- 2 tablespoons vegetable oil or melted butter
- 3 teaspoons baking powder
- sprinkle of salt
- butter or cooking spray for cooking
- Preheat a nonstick pan over medium heat.
- In a medium bowl, beat the egg with a fork or whisk until fluffy.
- Add remaining ingredients except butter/cooking spray. Mix just until combined, the batter should be thick and lumpy. You may even start to see it puff up a bit as the baking powder reacts.
- You can test that the pan is hot by sprinkling a bit of water in. It should sizzle and skip. Add the butter or cooking spray. Pour batter into rounds in the pan. I usually go three at a time.
- When the pancakes are golden brown on the bottom and bubbles are just starting to appear on the surface, flip. I like to flip before too many of the air bubbles have broken the surface, since this makes them rise higher.
- When browned on the second side and cooked through, remove from pan. Repeat with remaining batter, serve with maple syrup.
Once you have your pancake masterpieces, please do not even think of pouring Aunt Jemima’s on them. Buy the real stuff. Maple syrup. In particular the nice amber varieties from Quebec are my favorite.


